Schwankenstein’s Monster

Assortment of Links and Stories of Interest

Kindle vs Sony Cagematch

Update: Feb 2009:

Amazon just started accepting preorders on the Kindle 2, which solves many of the complaints that people, including my wife, had about the original.  

Full details here: Amazon Kindle 2




Some of you know that I am a big fan of my Amazon Kindle. What you don’t know is that my wife prefers the Sony Reader. In this showdown, we go husband versus wife in a battle royal comparing the strengths and weaknesses of each device from our unique perspectives. Game On:

My Arguments:

I believe in substance over style and the Kindle is a superior device to the Sony Reader.

Wireless. The wireless functionality puts the Kindle in its own class. Wireless is the kind of essential functionality that people will eventually take for granted as eBook readers become more mainstream. “Mommy, tell me again what it was like when you were a kid and people connected their devices to a computer with a cable.” I am a technology junky and even I don’t like the hassle of having to find a cable and plugging my devices into the computer. I can browse a huge library of books and have them delivered wirelessly to my device. TheeInk technology that powers both devices is cool, but by itself it doesn’t do much more than a regular book. Wireless connectivity gives Kindle users instant access to Amazon’s entire library of ebooks, which is the kind of technology that borders on magic.

Better Conversion. Amazon makes it easy to get your own content on the Kindle. They give users an email
address linked directly to the device. This means if you email a Word document or a PDF to it automatically is converted and sent wirelessly to your device.The conversion of PDFs runs an optical character recognition on the document and creates clean crisp text for the book. Amazon also automatically recognizes the table of contents and maps it to the various part of the book. Before I bought the Kindle, I tried putting a few PDF’son my wife’s Sony Reader, and they were illegible. The Sony was displaying the pages as graphics instead of text, which on the small screen just didn’t work. The Kindle’s high quality conversion means that you aren’t as locked-in to Amazon’s ebook store. A couple days ago I downloaded a science fiction book called Accelerando by Charlie Stross. What’s great about that is that Accelarando is published under a Creative Commons license, which means I can read it for free or even give a copy to a friend. If you are interested, you can download a copy here, friend). Moving Accelarando onto the Kindle was as easy as emailing it to myself. I really hope this kind of functionality helps people like Stross succeed. I am a few chapters into the book and it is outstanding. Sending books to yourself wirelessly costs ten cents, but you can email files to and they will reply to your email with converted files you can move to the Kindle by USB for free.




Sony is Evil. I would prefer to give my money to almost any technology company before Sony. Based on their previous products, the heavy imposition of DRM, and root-kit copy protection, I think it is fair to say that they hate their customers. They have historically tried to lock customers into proprietary formats like the Betamax, minidisc, and now blue-ray.Sony’s ownership of both the content and the hardware has caused them to put out crippled products that are anti-consumer, and I don’t see any reason to expect the Sony Reader to be any different.

Book Cost. One of the downsides of both the readers is that they are tied to the manufacturers’ stores (everyone wants to be like Apple’s iTunes). The difference here is that books on the Kindle cost less. When my wife and I compare prices for the same book, it is typically a couple dollars cheaper on my Kindle. I assume as competition increases, Sony will get their prices in line, although once you are locked into their platform all you can do is hope. Another cost saver is that Amazon will send you the first 20 or so pages of books in their store for free as a sample. The samples show up instantly and give me a chance to see if the book is going to be any good before I buy.

Newspapers and Blogs. The Kindle’s wireless functionality allows me to subscribe to newspapers and blogs and
have them delivered automatically to the device. I am not a big newspaper fan, but there are a number of really good blogs that I am glad to have with me on the go. The best one I have found is Wharton’s Knowledge@Wharton, which has magazine quality and is delivered to my Kindle weekly for $1 a month.


Amazon Cares More. Amazon has invested a lot in the Kindle. It is known to be a personal pet project of Amazon’s CEO Jeff Bezos. This means the development of the platform will get attention. When Amazon makes improvements to the Kindle software, the updates will be pushed down automatically. The Sony Reader, on the other hand, is a very small part of Sony’s business.

Built-In Dictionary. The Kindle has a built in dictionary (and free access to wikipedia) that allows you to highlight any word in a book you are reading and look it up. I have been using this feature a lot. I thought about giving Sony a pass on this one, since the Amazon dictionary and wikipedia access on the Kindle are tied to its wireless, but lack of wireless on the Sony is no excuse for not including a dictionary. Sony could have incorporated a dictionary into their
reader, but didn’t.


In summary, the Kindle is a superior machine. While it lacks the Sony’s style, it makes up for it with functionality, and the whole point is to read, not just look pretty.


Stacy’s Arguments:

Carrying a Sony reader means not carrying around a piece of crap.


I bought my Sony PRS505 reader a month or so before I had even heard about the Amazon reader.

I thought that I might have buyers remorse once I saw the Kindle due to all the hype I had heard, and after barely hearing anything about the Sony, and so anxiously awaited the arrival of my husbands Kindle in January. I was the one to pick up the package from the doorstop, but was asked not to open it until he got home. So anticipation mounted with doubts flickering through my mind, until… I saw it. I could not believe, and still can’t, that THIS was what Amazon had created!

Size. It is HUGE! Amazon shows the Kindle on its website as being as thick as a pencil. I don’t think so! And once you put it in its humongous case, forget about it. You may as well be carrying a 600 pg novel around with you! In contrast, the Sony IS as slim as a pencil and the sleek leather case adds about only 1/3 of an inch.


Cases. Even the cases are like day and night. The Sony’s is smooth, high quality leather that feels nice in your hand with a good weight to it. It is really a classy looking piece of technology, and is held shut by hidden magnets. The Kindle case is, as I mentioned earlier, huge. It has a low quality grainy leather that bags away from the piece of cardboard that gives it its structure. The tabs of flimsy leather on the inside, which I think are supposed to protect the inner corners of the kindle from damage, bulge out of the case giving it a real half-assed look. And the closing mechanism on this $400 Kindle? A simple piece of elastic.And that elastic on my husbands kindle is already rolling and stretched.


Durability. Now, you have to have a case so that you do not scratch or damage your $300-$400 toy. Well, no one told Amazon that they might want to make it so that when the case is opened, the Kindle wouldn’t just fall out on the ground! There is only a clip in the back of the case that levers the Kindle in place so that it doesn’t slide around. Bad idea Amazon! The thing is constantly falling out of the case when you would least expect it. So one false moveand BOOM! Your $400 machine is no more. Honestly I am just waiting for that to happen to my husband. And again, in contrast, the Sony is attached to its case and the only way you can get it out is if you read the instruction manual, but I have yet to find a reason to remove it.

Metal vs. Plastic. On top of the Kindle just waiting to become scrap metal on the ground, the thing is not even METAL! It is white plastic. That was a big shock after using the Sony, which IS metal. The plastic of the Kindle furthers the real cheap, low quality feel of it. So whoa to the individual who opens their flimsy case and lets fall their plastic time bomb. What was Amazon thinking?

Button Placement. Now don’t push that button, I have more to say. What’s that? You can’t help but push that button? You must be using a Kindle. The buttons on the Kindle cover the edges of both the right and left side of the device, you
know, where you like to hold it? When you start to read on your Kindle, you have everything just where you want it… until you move that is. Boom! Next page. Wham! Menu page. Pow! Different book entirely! Kaboom! Screen saver! Where am I? The buttons are placed so badly I have to wonder who was in charge of the design of this thing! Oh wait,
what design. The thing is hideous.


Wireless is Overrated. Alright, I have to admit that wireless is pretty good in this day and age, but Amazon
charges every time you send something to your Kindle, and that can add up. With the Sony, you have to plug it into your computer maybe once a month for some new books (you can have over a hundred books on your Sony at any one time. How often will you really be plugging it in?), for 5 minutes at the most. And it’s free.

Cost. Yes, it is true what they say, books from Amazon are a little cheaper on the average, but remember
that there is an extra charge for anything else you may want to send to your device. Plus, if you add the $100 more you paid for the Kindle to begin with… sucker.

Content is Comparable. I read a LOT, and am so happy that these readers are out there. And yes, it does suck to buy a book that then sits in your virtual library forever due to the fact that you can’t sell it due to DRM, but that is true for both devices. No one is going to make it easier for people out there to rip off the authors that spent years creating these wonderful stories, so we have to get used to this. So even though my husband stated that he downloaded books from Creative Commons for free, authors are not going to give their work out for free very often.

To give the Kindle a fair try, I decided to carry it around with me for a few days and read one of my books. That lasted for about one day. As I stated before, the thing is bulky and awkward, and fell out of the case every time I opened it. My Sony on the other hand slides right in to a small pocket in my purse, and guys, that just isn’t going to happen with the Kindle.

Final words, I, as an avid reader, appreciate the Sony’s sleek style and comfortable design. If I wanted one, I would have a Kindle, but the only thing that I can see that is fueling the need for the Kindle is the advertising Amazon has allotted to it. When I carry around the Sony Reader I get comments on it all the time. When I carry the Kindle, people are afraid to ask about the unwieldy monstrosity in my lap. The Kindle is not a good conversation point, until that time when it slips from your hand and smashes on the ground. Then you will hear plenty of painful groans from the people around you who just witnessed the destruction of your wasted $400.

Let us know which device you prefer, and if you post questions we will each chime in with answers.



This article has been moved to our redesigned website at

Click here to be forwarded to the redesigned website.

Sorry for the inconvinence. Website growing pains. Thanks for understanding.

March 1, 2008 - Posted by | kindle, Uncategorized | ,


  1. Yep, I am so glad I went with the PRS-505! It just fits into my hand like it was made specially for me. Wireless, shmireless!

    Comment by Jim Price | March 7, 2009 | Reply

  2. With the sony reader, its open format, i have only payed for 2 out of the 200+ books i have, and thats because i couldnt find copies online. The kindle pretty much forces you to buy book from their store, or else your going to pay obnoxious fee’s, not to mention the horrible design of the device itself. Yes, wireless is amazing, ill give it that, but the Sony Reader is so much more open, and now with their partnership with Google, they have added over 500,000 more books to their ebook library. FOR FREE. Thats something that amazon doesnt have.

    Comment by Nathan S. | March 26, 2009 | Reply

  3. “Sony’s ownership of both the content and the hardware …”

    Excuse me? Is this Sony or Amazon that owns and controls both the content and the hardware? Didn’t you just say that you cannot upload anything on your Kindle without Amazon’s service? They not only own the content they are providing, they also control the content you own!

    Comment by Dmitry | April 24, 2009 | Reply

  4. Wow, this post is fastidious, my sister is analyzing these things,
    thus I am going to inform her.

    Comment by Nuvalift | June 24, 2013 | Reply

  5. Excellent blog you have got here.. It’s difficult to find quality writing like yours these days. I honestly appreciate people like you! Take care!!

    Comment by Cairns | July 15, 2013 | Reply

  6. I am actually happy to glance at this webpage posts which
    carries tons of useful facts, thanks for providing such statistics.

    Comment by cairns online travel agent | July 16, 2013 | Reply

  7. It’s remarkable in favor of me to have a web site, which is valuable for my know-how. thanks admin

    Comment by Cairns overnight marlin fishing | July 25, 2013 | Reply

  8. It’s not my first time to visit this web page, i am browsing this website dailly and get nice data from here everyday.

    Comment by marlin fishing charter | July 26, 2013 | Reply

  9. It’s not my first time to pay a quick visit this site, i am browsing this site dailly and obtain nice facts from here all the time.

    Comment by scuba diving jobs | July 29, 2013 | Reply

  10. Today, while I was at work, my cousin stole my iPad and tested to
    see if it can survive a 40 foot drop, just so she can be a youtube sensation.
    My iPad is now destroyed and she has 83 views. I know this is entirely off topic but I had to share
    it with someone!

    Comment by australia cairns | August 2, 2013 | Reply

  11. You’ve got a superb blog post. Will you add more articles regularly.
    I’ve shared it in fb!I really hope you don’t mind too.

    Comment by free ipad | September 12, 2013 | Reply

  12. you’re actually a excellent webmaster. The website loading velocity is incredible.
    It seems that you’re doing any distinctive trick. Moreover,
    Thhe contents are masterwork. you’ve performed a excellent activity on this subject!

    Comment by petua kempiskan perut | October 2, 2013 | Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: